The trouble with Maslow's hierarchy of needs ...


You know the pyramid, right? With food and water at the bottom, then safety, belonging, and esteem, and self-actualization sitting in a tiny triangle at the top.

I’ve seen this in more PD sessions than I can count over the last 25 years, and I always assumed Abraham Maslow drew it.

But he never did, not once in any of his published work.

The first published version of the pyramid showed up in 1960, in a business journal article called “How Money Motivates Men,” where a consulting psychologist argued the pyramid could help managers get maximum motivation out of workers at the lowest cost.

Maslow himself described human needs as fluid, with lots of them operating at the same time, which sends a very different message than a pyramid you have to climb one level at a time.

That difference matters in schools more than you might realize.

When we take “Maslow before Bloom” literally, it’s easy to end up with one group of students debating whether their town should build a new skate park, while across town, kids get a worksheet packet because somebody decided they weren’t ready for higher-order thinking yet.

Nobody sets out to lower expectations for those kids, but the pyramid makes the decision feel logical, and even kind.

The version most of us learned is missing something else, too. Late in his life, Maslow added a level above self-actualization, and it changes how we think about what kids (and adults) need in order to grow. It connects to six weeks he spent with the Blackfoot indigenous people in 1938, where what he saw turned a lot of his assumptions upside down.

​In the latest Truth for Teachers podcast episode, I get into the missing level, the research behind it, and one way to build it into your classroom this week, including for the kids who are struggling the most.

If you’d rather read, the full transcript is on the blog.

Enjoy!

Angela
​
P.S. I've also made a YouTube video essay on how Maslow’s self-actualization got rebranded as a wellness trend (and tied it to Don Draper's experience in the Mad Men finale.)

Angela Watson

Connect with our community of educators:

PODCAST
CURRICULUM
BOOKS
COURSES
SPEAKING
​

P.O. Box 175, Bushkill, PA 18324​

Unsubscribe

Truth for Teachers

Join over 92,000 teachers who receive our Sunday night emails, and get inspired + informed for the week ahead.

Read more from Truth for Teachers
Dark clouds silhouetted against a faint glow on the horizon at night

The clocks went back last night. 🙁 That means that by the end of this week, most of us in the U.S. will soon be walking out of school during sunset or even pitch black. Your body is going to read that darkness as a sign the day is over, even though you've still got dinner to make and about many more hours of being a responsible adult ahead of you. I know how those evenings tend to go for me if I'm not paying attention. It's dark and cold, I'm tired, and the couch is right there, so I pick up...

"For every 2 hour class I taught this year, I spent about 8 hours at home preparing." That's a quote from Jennifer Gonzalez of Cult of Pedagogy who provides English as a Second Language instruction to adults in her community. Jenn, if you don't know her work or podcast, is someone who taught middle school for years, trained pre-service teachers at the university level, and has studied effective instruction for well over two decades ... ... and planning STILL took her that long. I found that...

I used to think my perfectionism made me good at my job. Turns out it was making me slow, exhausted, and avoidant. Sometimes perfectionism isn’t about high standards at all. Sometimes it’s about fear of judgment. Or, fear that if we don’t control every detail, something will fall apart, so we have to anticipate every possible outcome and try to solve for it in advance. (If you’ve ever rewritten a two-line email to your principal four times, or stayed up redoing a slide nobody else would...